Rating 93
Style
Produced In England
ABV 40%
Availability Year Round
Price $35.00 
Reviewed By
Reviewed 2026-08-04

James Gin American Mustard Review

There is the intense aroma of French’s yellow mustard on the nose of this unconventional British gin, giving you an immediate WTF?! sensation. Dive in for a sip and it’s even more savory: mustard, coriander, anise seed, maybe some tangy relish notes … and are you just imagining a hint of beefy hot dog ? It’s jarring. And then you keep going back for another sip and soon realize: this works. It’s no gimmick, but, rather, one of the more interesting, more cohesive craft gins out there. Not to be missed.

As of 2024, VinePair no longer participates in any affiliate programs. All links included in our content are as a convenience to our readers, not for earning commission — we receive no monetary value from them. Learn more about our tastings & review department here!

93
POINTS
James Gin American Mustard
There is the intense aroma of French’s yellow mustard on the nose of this unconventional British gin, giving you an immediate WTF?! sensation. Dive in for a sip and it’s even more savory: mustard, coriander, anise seed, maybe some tangy relish notes … and are you just imagining a hint of beefy hot dog ? It’s jarring. And then you keep going back for another sip and soon realize: this works. It’s no gimmick, but, rather, one of the more interesting, more cohesive craft gins out there. Not to be missed.

Reviewed On: 08-04-2026
93
POINTS
James Gin American Mustard
There is the intense aroma of French’s yellow mustard on the nose of this unconventional British gin, giving you an immediate WTF?! sensation. Dive in for a sip and it’s even more savory: mustard, coriander, anise seed, maybe some tangy relish notes … and are you just imagining a hint of beefy hot dog ? It’s jarring. And then you keep going back for another sip and soon realize: this works. It’s no gimmick, but, rather, one of the more interesting, more cohesive craft gins out there. Not to be missed.

Reviewed On: 08-04-2026