The Story Behind The Urban Cowboy Lodge’s Hot Toddy

If you’re in the market for a Hot Toddy that goes beyond the original spec of just whiskey, honey, lemon juice, and hot water, Urban Cowboy Lodge’s riff is the Toddy for you. Developed by Harry McNamara, this version of the beloved winter classic elevates seasonal flavors like apple, winter citrus, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

Floral and bittersweet Amaro Montenegro is balanced by sweet bourbon with apple brandy and sherry further rounding out the base. Bitters and lemon juice keep things in check, and a whipped cream garnish is the rich, luscious topper every warm holiday cocktail needs.

Ingredients

  • 1 ounce Amaro Montenegro
  • 1 ounce Old Forester Bourbon
  • ¼ ounce Laird’s Apple Brandy
  • ½ ounce Lustau East India Solera Sherry
  • 1 dash Angostura bitters
  • 2 ounces water
  • ¼ ounce cinnamon syrup
  • ¼ ounce lemon juice
  • Garnish: whipped cream, an orange star, and shaved fresh nutmeg.

Directions

  1. In a pot, add all ingredients excluding cinnamon syrup and lemon juice and heat to near boiling.
  2. In a mug, add cinnamon syrup and lemon juice before pouring heated mixture into the mug.
  3. Top with a small dollop of whipped cream, an orange star, and shaved fresh nutmeg on top.

Rate This Recipe:

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
(33 votes)

Yield: 1
Updated: 2022-12-15

Urban Cowboy Lodge’s Hot Toddy

Related Reads & Recipes

Learn About Amaro

· Amaro 101

More Amaro Recipes To Explore

The Colonial Cocktail Recipe

The Colonial Cocktail Recipe:
Gin, Aperol, and sparkling wine come together in this bright, bubbly cocktail from NYC cafe Shoo Shoo. Learn how to make the recipe here.

The If Pizza Were a Cocktail Recipe

The If Pizza Were a Cocktail Recipe:
This French press cocktail recipe created by Tyler Zielinski for VinePair starts with a white wine base, and adds amaro, lemon, and fresh fruit.

The Toucan Sam Recipe

The Toucan Sam Recipe:
Campari, gin, and pineapple and lime juices come together in this bright and breezy cocktail from Mr. Purple bar in NYC. Learn how to make the recipe.

The Rosemary-Smoked Negroni Recipe

The Rosemary-Smoked Negroni Recipe:
The Negroni is a classic cocktail made with London dry gin and a popular Italian amaro, Campari. In this version, Natalie Migliarini balances its flavor profile with savory, smoky rosemary. Get the recipe here!

The Mexicano Recipe

The Mexicano Recipe:
Mezcal makes an appearance in this riff on the classic Americano cocktail that comes together in a snap. La buena vida, indeed.

The Honeysuckle Negroni Recipe

The Honeysuckle Negroni Recipe:
For this cocktail recipe, Natalie Migliarini riffs on a classic Negroni by incorporating dry vermouth and homemade honeysuckle simple syrup with Campari and gin. Learn how to make it here!