Rating 94
Style
Produced In Caribbean
ABV 47%
Availability Year Round
Price $33.00 
Reviewed By
Reviewed 2026-11-16

Probitas Green Blended Dark Rum Review

A new dark version of the beloved white mixing rum, Probitas Green also combines various Foursquare Rum and Hampden Estate distillates, some aged, that are then further colored (and made “dark”) with caramelized sugar produced by Foursquare. There are notes of caramel, brown butter, coconut, and tropical fruit; it’s intense but surprisingly drinkable for the higher proof (57 percent ABV). Just like its lighter-colored brethren, it too would be great in cocktails, especially those of the tropical variety like the Mai Tai, Painkiller, or even the Hurricane.

As of 2024, VinePair no longer participates in any affiliate programs. All links included in our content are as a convenience to our readers, not for earning commission — we receive no monetary value from them. Learn more about our tastings & review department here!

94
POINTS
Probitas Green Blended Dark Rum
A new dark version of the beloved white mixing rum, Probitas Green also combines various Foursquare Rum and Hampden Estate distillates, some aged, that are then further colored (and made “dark”) with caramelized sugar produced by Foursquare. There are notes of caramel, brown butter, coconut, and tropical fruit; it’s intense but surprisingly drinkable for the higher proof (57 percent ABV). Just like its lighter-colored brethren, it too would be great in cocktails, especially those of the tropical variety like the Mai Tai, Painkiller, or even the Hurricane.

Reviewed On: 11-16-2026
94
POINTS
Probitas Green Blended Dark Rum
A new dark version of the beloved white mixing rum, Probitas Green also combines various Foursquare Rum and Hampden Estate distillates, some aged, that are then further colored (and made “dark”) with caramelized sugar produced by Foursquare. There are notes of caramel, brown butter, coconut, and tropical fruit; it’s intense but surprisingly drinkable for the higher proof (57 percent ABV). Just like its lighter-colored brethren, it too would be great in cocktails, especially those of the tropical variety like the Mai Tai, Painkiller, or even the Hurricane.

Reviewed On: 11-16-2026