The simplest answer to this question is that small-batch bourbon is a very clever form of marketing. There is no federal regulation that defines what makes a bourbon “small-batch,” or a batch small, for that matter. Therefore, the only proven use of the term is to sell bourbon — a good amount of bourbon.

Labeling select bourbons as small-batch started in the 1990s and took off in the early aughts as the craft movement was growing. Producers, both large and small, were looking for a way to signify that the liquid inside their bottles was “craft.” Small-batch came to signify artisanal, and gave labels the crafty appeal many consumers were looking for.

Some producers will tell you that their small-batch bourbon does have a true meaning. For example, the liquid inside the bottle was blended from only a very limited amount of barrels. Although this is true in certain cases, for bigger brands that have small-batch offerings, those limited amounts of barrels could number in the thousands — a small batch for them, maybe, but not what a whiskey drinker might think when they read “small” on the label. In other words, it’s all relative.

Get the latest in beer, wine, and cocktail culture sent straight to your inbox.